Looking for the best downtown Italian restaurants in Buenos Aires? Whether you’re a digital nomad, traveler, or expat, the rich Italian heritage of Buenos Aires is evident in its vibrant culinary scene.
Many Italian families emigrated here during the 19th and 20th centuries, leaving a lasting impact on the city’s culture and cuisine.
This influence can be seen not only in the way Argentines communicate but also in the unique character of its restaurants and bars. For those seeking high-quality Italian dining with authentic flavors not found outside Italy, Buenos Aires is the place to be.
ExpatPathways has curated a list of the top 10 downtown Italian restaurants that offer an unforgettable dining experience in this culturally rich city.
The Best Downtown Italian Restaurants in Buenos Aires
1. Broccolino
Location: Esmeralda 776.
Founded by the Trío family in 1985, Broccolino has become a staple in the microcentro of Buenos Aires, continually reinventing itself while honoring its roots. The name pays homage to the Italian immigrants who settled in Brooklyn, New York, after the first waves of migration.
Initially starting as a traditional pizzeria, Broccolino has evolved over the years, incorporating a variety of Italian dishes into its menu. Patrons can enjoy delights such as deer ravioli with Alfredo sauce, tagliatelle all’amatriciana, and the famous Broccolino calamaretti, which are flambéed in white wine.
Broccolino is renowned for its excellent service and high-quality food, with many visitors praising the exceptional flavors and generous portions.
The restaurant’s vibrant atmosphere and commitment to using fresh ingredients have made it a must-visit destination for both locals and tourists. Whether it’s the rich risotto, the perfectly cooked meats, or the homemade pasta, Broccolino consistently delivers a memorable dining experience that keeps customers coming back.
2. Ristorante Maria Fedele
Location: Adolfo Alsina 1465.
Ristorante Maria Fedele began as a small family venture in the San Telmo neighborhood and has since become a beloved fixture in Buenos Aires’ culinary scene. Known for its Calabrian-style Italian cuisine, Maria Fedele offers an intimate dining experience with a focus on authenticity and tradition.
The restaurant’s four-course fixed-price menu is a highlight, featuring an abundance of antipasto, exquisite pasta dishes, a savory meat and salad course, and a selection of delightful desserts.
Guests often rave about the warm and inviting atmosphere, complemented by live accordion music that enhances the dining experience. The exceptional service and the quality of the food make Maria Fedele a standout choice for those seeking rustic, genuine Italian fare.
Whether dining with a large group or enjoying a romantic evening, this hidden gem promises an unforgettable experience filled with flavors that transport you straight to Italy.
3. D’oro Italian Bar
Location: Perú 159.
D’oro Italian Bar, founded in 1999, brings together the culinary expertise gained in Rome and the successful ventures in Miami to create an exceptional dining experience in Buenos Aires.
The restaurant is known for its commitment to quality, offering a menu that reflects the diverse influences from Italy, Japan, Vietnam, and Thailand. With two generations of Italian heritage and culinary school training, D’oro Italian Bar stands out for its dedication to excellence and innovation.
The restaurant’s ambiance is warm and welcoming, with attentive service that ensures every detail is perfect. Patrons can enjoy a variety of expertly prepared dishes, from pasta with salmon and black squid ink to rich and flavorful desserts.
The complimentary starter, signature drinks, and freshly baked bread add a special touch to the dining experience. Whether you’re enjoying a solo meal or a gathering with friends, D’oro Italian Bar offers a delightful taste of Italy right in the heart of Buenos Aires.
4. Il Sorpasso
Location: Humberto 1ª 478.
Located just meters from Plaza San Telmo, Il Sorpasso is a hidden gem housed in a historic building that exudes old-world charm. This restaurant offers traditional Italian cuisine with a unique twist, blending inherited and modern decor elements to create a captivating dining atmosphere.
Il Sorpasso is renowned for its cozy ambiance, excellent service, and affordable prices. The pasta dishes are particularly noteworthy, with patrons often raving about their flavor and quality.
Il Sorpasso is also a popular venue for corporate events, where the impeccable service and delicious food consistently impress guests. The menu features a wide array of appetizers, including stuffed focaccia and salmon bruschettas, as well as standout main courses like veal with potato mille-feuille.
The restaurant’s beautiful setting and exquisite cuisine make it a perfect spot for those who appreciate the blend of history and fine dining. Whether you’re dining solo or hosting a group, Il Sorpasso promises an exceptional Italian dining experience.
5. La Parolaccia Trattoria
Location: Av. Alicia Moreau de Justo 1052.
La Parolaccia Trattoria, with roots tracing back to Trastevere, Rome, has been a staple in Buenos Aires for over 28 years. The name, which translates to “The Bad Word,” reflects the warm, welcoming, and slightly cheeky hospitality that defines this beloved restaurant.
Known for its authentic Italian flavors and high-quality service, La Parolaccia offers a diverse menu where pasta dishes take center stage. The restaurant has become synonymous with exceptional Italian dining in Buenos Aires.
Guests at La Parolaccia are treated to a delightful culinary experience, starting with complimentary aperitifs and freshly baked bread. The lasagna is often cited as one of the best in the city, and the cheese sticks are highly recommended.
The ambiance is perfect for celebrating special occasions, with numerous birthdays celebrated nightly. With top-notch service and a cozy atmosphere, La Parolaccia ensures a memorable dining experience that keeps patrons coming back time and time again.
6. Cucina De Santo
Location: Talcahuano 475.
Cucina De Santo is a well-kept secret among the office workers, lawyers, judges, tourists, and regulars who frequent the Tribunales area. Tucked away on the first floor of an old office building on Talcahuano Street, this hidden gem is not easy to find by chance.
Once inside, diners are welcomed by a warm, elegantly dressed waiter into a charming dining room adorned with red and white checkered tablecloths, chandeliers, and candelabras.
The pasta at Cucina De Santo is unparalleled, with homemade dishes that transport you straight to Italy. Highlights include the antipasto starter, homemade noodles with shrimp, and the fish of the day, all of which receive rave reviews. The tiramisu is a must-try, often described as one of the best in the city.
Despite its somewhat hidden location, the restaurant offers a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere with attentive service and delicious food at very reasonable prices. For those in the know, Cucina De Santo is a culinary treasure worth discovering.
7. Cincinnati Pizza
Location: Esmeralda 924.
Cincinnati Pizza offers a traditional Italian pizza experience, standing out in a city where thick, heavy pizzas are the norm. Located near the bustling theater district, it provides a tranquil setting with clean, modern decor and attentive service.
The pizzas are thin-crust with just the right amount of sauce and mozzarella, delivering a taste of Italy in every bite. Patrons particularly enjoy the four-cheese pizza and the fresh, flavorful salads.
The hospitality at Cincinnati Pizza is top-notch, with staff members who go out of their way to make diners feel welcome. The cozy atmosphere and excellent food make it a favorite spot for both locals and visitors.
With affordable prices and a reputation for delicious, high-quality pizza, Cincinnati Pizza is a must-visit for anyone looking to enjoy a genuine Italian meal in Buenos Aires. The open kitchen, where you can watch your pizza being prepared, adds to the charm and ensures a delightful dining experience.
8. Rigoletto Restaurant
Location: Rodríguez Peña 1291.
Rigoletto Restaurant offers an intimate and cozy dining experience with a focus on fresh, homemade pasta. Located in the heart of Buenos Aires, this charming restaurant is known for its attentive service and delightful ambiance.
The menu features a variety of Italian classics, including fresh pasta dishes, hearty meat entrees, and delicious desserts. The homemade pasta is a standout, with dishes like lasagna and tiramisu receiving high praise from patrons.
Visitors appreciate the consistency in quality and the welcoming atmosphere, making Rigoletto a reliable choice for both casual meals and special occasions. The restaurant opens early and stays open late, catering to a wide range of dining needs.
Whether you’re stopping by for a quick lunch or a leisurely dinner, Rigoletto’s excellent service and delicious food make it a top choice for Italian cuisine in Buenos Aires. The reasonable prices and extensive menu ensure there’s something for everyone to enjoy.
9. Le Famiglie
Location: Salta 440.
Le Famiglie is a classic Buenos Aires cantina that specializes in hearty, homemade Italian food. The restaurant offers a welcoming and cozy atmosphere, perfect for family gatherings and long, leisurely meals.
The menu is extensive, featuring a wide range of appetizers, main courses, and desserts, all prepared with care and attention to detail. The gnocchi is particularly popular, praised for its light, fluffy texture and rich sauces.
Service at Le Famiglie is exceptional, with professional and friendly waitstaff who make every effort to ensure a pleasant dining experience. The restaurant is known for its excellent value, offering high-quality food at reasonable prices.
Whether you’re enjoying a casual dinner or celebrating a special occasion, Le Famiglie provides a warm and inviting setting with delicious, authentic Italian cuisine. The extensive wine list and well-curated menu make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
10. Prosciutto Ristorante
Location: Junín 283.
Prosciutto Ristorante is housed in a beautifully restored 1893 mansion, blending historic charm with modern elegance. Located on the corner of Sarmiento and Junin, this restaurant offers a unique dining experience with its carefully preserved Italian architectural influences.
The menu features a wide array of Italian dishes, with a particular focus on fresh pasta and traditional sauces. The bolognese sauce is a standout, known for its rich flavor and hearty texture.
The ambiance at Prosciutto Ristorante is both elegant and welcoming, with antique decor and a family-friendly atmosphere. Service is prompt and attentive, ensuring a pleasant dining experience from start to finish.
The executive menus are especially popular, offering a complete and affordable dining option. Whether you’re in the mood for a romantic dinner or a casual meal with friends, Prosciutto Ristorante provides a delightful setting and delicious food that will leave you wanting to come back for more.
(Featured Image Source: Gabriella Clare Marino/unsplash.com)
